A Wife's Inability to Perform Marital Obligations as a Ground for Polygamy: An Analysis of Judicial Reasoning in Cases Involving Women with Disabilities

  • Citra Widyasari Universitas Islam Negeri Sunan Kalijaga, Indonesia
  • Mukarramah Universitas Tomakaka, Indonesia
  • Ahmad Fathorrozi Universitas Islam Negeri Sunan Kalijaga, Indonesia
Keywords: Polygamy Permits; Women With Disabilities; Ratio Decidendi; Judicial Reasoning.

Abstract

Article 57 of the Compilation of Islamic Law (KHI) permits polygamy when a wife is unable to fulfill her duties as a wife. A problem arises when such inability is associated with an illness or condition that may be categorized as a disability, since a medical condition is not necessarily synonymous with functional incapacity. This study aims to analyze the legal reasoning of judges (ratio decidendi) in applications for permission to practice polygamy based on the wife's disability before the Religious Courts. This study employs an empirical legal research method using a socio-legal approach and a case approach. Data were obtained through document analysis of court decisions sourced from the Supreme Court Decision Directory and copies of decisions from several Religious Courts in Indonesia, selected through purposive sampling.The findings show that all applications for permission to practice polygamy in the eight analyzed decisions were granted by the judges. Five of the eight decisions (62.5%) were supported by medical evidence, while three decisions (37.5%) relied solely on witness testimony. The conditions underlying the applications included physical, mental, and reproductive disabilities, as well as degenerative diseases. The evidence presented was generally sufficient to establish the existence of a health condition, but did not consistently examine its severity, nature and persistence, prognosis, or impact on the wife's overall marital functioning. Judges tended to interpret Article 57 of the KHI broadly by linking the wife's disability to an inability to fulfill marital duties or reproductive functions as grounds for granting permission for polygamy. Judicial assessment of the wife's inability focused primarily on the relationship between the health condition and particular marital functions considered unfulfilled, rather than on a comprehensive assessment of her functional capacity. Consequently, impairment or a medical condition tends to serve as the starting point for establishing incapacity, without always explaining how the condition produces functional limitations that are legally relevant.

Published
2026-10-20
How to Cite
Widyasari, C., Mukarramah, & Fathorrozi, A. (2026). A Wife’s Inability to Perform Marital Obligations as a Ground for Polygamy: An Analysis of Judicial Reasoning in Cases Involving Women with Disabilities. Proceeding of International Conference on Sharia and Law, 4(1), 129-159. Retrieved from https://proceedings.uinsa.ac.id/index.php/ICOSLAW/article/view/5252