The Application of Ne Bis In Idem in Domestic Abuse and Neglect Cases: Analyzing Legal Protection and Women's Children's Rights

  • Anggi Purnama Tradesa Universitas Nahdlatul Ulama, Nusa Tenggara Barat
  • Agis Setiawan Universitas Nahdlatul Ulama, Nusa Tenggara Barat
  • Angga Dinata Universitas Mataram
Keywords: Ne Bis In Idem, maltreatment, domestic neglect, domestic violence, protection of women and children, legal certainty

Abstract

The principle of Ne Bis In Idem constitutes a fundamental safeguard within Indonesia's criminal justice system, ensuring that no individual is prosecuted twice for the same criminal act after a final judgment, as stipulated in Article 76 of the Indonesian Criminal Code. However, its application becomes problematic in cases of domestic violence involving continuing offenses, particularly when physical abuse and domestic neglect arise from the same sequence of events. This study examines whether such acts should be regarded as a single criminal event subject to Ne Bis In Idem or as legally distinct offenses requiring separate adjudication.This research employs a normative juridical method using statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches. The analysis demonstrates that determining the applicability of Ne Bis In Idem should not rely solely on the formal similarity of criminal charges but must consider the material identity of the offense, including the perpetrator, time, place, motive, and factual sequence of events. Domestic assault and domestic neglect possess different legal characteristics and produce distinct forms of harm. Physical violence causes immediate bodily and psychological injury, whereas neglect constitutes a continuing offense that results in prolonged economic deprivation and threatens the welfare of women and children. Consequently, treating both acts as the same criminal event may undermine victims' access to justice and weaken legal protection. Comparative analysis indicates that several jurisdictions adopt a transactional approach, recognizing separate prosecutions where different harms arise from related criminal conduct. Based on these findings, this study proposes three models for balancing legal certainty and victim protection: Harm Differentiation Analysis, requiring judges to distinguish the legal harms addressed in each prosecution; Prosecution Integration, encouraging prosecutors to consolidate related offenses through joinder of charges; and Victim-Oriented Interpretation, prioritizing the protection of women and children when interpreting continuing domestic violence cases. The study further recommends the issuance of specific judicial guidelines concerning the application of Ne Bis In Idem to continuing offenses, enhanced gender-sensitive training for law enforcement officials, and greater reliance on expert testimony regarding continuing delicts. These measures are expected to strengthen legal certainty while ensuring comprehensive protection of victims' rights within Indonesia's criminal justice system.

Published
2026-10-20
How to Cite
Anggi Purnama Tradesa, Agis Setiawan, & Angga Dinata. (2026). The Application of Ne Bis In Idem in Domestic Abuse and Neglect Cases: Analyzing Legal Protection and Women’s Children’s Rights. Proceeding of International Conference on Sharia and Law, 4(1), 289-308. Retrieved from https://proceedings.uinsa.ac.id/index.php/ICOSLAW/article/view/5258