Reconstructing Women's Rights Protection in Surrogacy Practices Based on Living Law: Perspectives of Customary Law, Human Rights, and Islamic Law
Abstract
The rapid advancement of assisted reproductive technology has introduced surrogacy as a cross-border reproductive practice that raises complex legal, ethical, and human rights questions. In Indonesia, the absence of comprehensive regulation creates uncertainty over the protection of women's reproductive rights, the legal position of surrogate mothers, and the status of children born through surrogacy. Existing scholarship tends to examine surrogacy from either religious or civil-law perspectives in isolation, leaving limited attention to how customary values, human rights standards, and religious legal reasoning might be read together. This study aims to reconstruct a model of legal protection for women involved in surrogacy by integrating customary law, human rights, and religious legal values through the lens of living law. The research employs normative legal methods, combining statutory, conceptual, comparative, case, and socio-legal approaches, supported by a review of recent scholarly literature. The findings show that customary values emphasizing kinship, dignity, communal responsibility, and the protection of women and children align closely with international human rights principles and with the higher objectives pursued by religious legal reasoning, particularly the preservation of lineage, life, and honor. Based on this convergence, the study proposes a holistic regulatory framework capable of delivering justice, legal certainty, and comprehensive protection for women and children within Indonesia's pluralistic legal system, while cautioning against the risks of commodification and exploitation inherent in unregulated surrogacy arrangements.
