Inequality of Bargaining Power and Vitiated Consent in Agricultural Profit-Sharing Contracts

Towards Gender Responsive Civil Law Reform

  • Etika Rahmawati Universitas Terbuka
  • Muhammad Alamul Huda Yamani Syarif Abdurrahman College of Sharia Sciences, Indonesia
  • Tri Minarti Kapuas University, Indonesia
Keywords: Vitiated Consent; Bargaining Power; Profit-Sharing Contracts; Gender Responsive; Civil Law Reform.

Abstract

Inequality of bargaining power remains a pervasive structural issue in agricultural profit-sharing agreements, frequently resulting in vitiated consent (misbruik van omstandigheden), particularly for female farmers. Despite their foundational role in agricultural production, female farmers often lack formalized land ownership, which serves as the primary capital and collateral in rural economies. This systemic disparity, compounded by the non-recognition of unmonetized reproductive labor, forces them into subordinate negotiating positions with landowners, where informal oral arrangements (maro, mertelu) systematically shift production costs and climate risks onto them. The primary objective of this study is to critically analyze the legal implications of unequal bargaining power and defective consent in agricultural contracts, while formulating a progressive framework for gender-responsive civil law reform. Employing a normative juridical method through statute and conceptual approaches, this research investigates contractual power dynamics by critically examining existing doctrinal principles through a feminist legal perspective. The findings indicate that prevalent informal profit-sharing practices systematically disadvantage female farmers. Their consent is compromised by economic necessity and structural dependency, fulfilling the criteria for undue influence under the law of obligations. Furthermore, the existing legal framework governing agricultural tenancy (Law No. 2 of 1960) fails to explicitly accommodate gendered vulnerabilities. Therefore, a comprehensive civil law reform is imperative. This reform must operate through two pivotal mechanisms; encouraging progressive judicial intervention (rechtsvinding) to execute contractual adjustments based on the principle of proportionality, and institutionalizing standardized, gender-responsive written contracts at the regulatory and village levels to ensure substantive justice and tenure security for female farmers.

Published
2026-10-24
How to Cite
Etika Rahmawati, Yamani, M. A. H., & Minarti, T. (2026). Inequality of Bargaining Power and Vitiated Consent in Agricultural Profit-Sharing Contracts : Towards Gender Responsive Civil Law Reform. Proceeding of International Conference on Sharia and Law, 4(1), 309-340. Retrieved from https://proceedings.uinsa.ac.id/index.php/ICOSLAW/article/view/5266